• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

MassDevice

The Medical Device Business Journal — Medical Device News & Articles | MassDevice

  • Latest News
    • Cardiovascular
    • Orthopedics
  • Wall Street Beat
    • Funding Roundup
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Podcasts & Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
  • Resources
    • About MassDevice
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Leadership in Medtech
    • Manufacturers & Suppliers Search
    • MedTech 100 Index
    • Videos
    • Whitepapers
  • DeviceTalks Tuesdays
  • Coronavirus: Live updates
Home » UPDATE: FDA panel inconclusive on power morcellators

UPDATE: FDA panel inconclusive on power morcellators

July 14, 2014 By Ingrid Mezo

UPDATE: FDA panel inconclusive on power morcellators

An FDA panel convened last week to consider the use of a controversial procedure to remove uterine fibroids failed to come to a clear decision on the cancer risk from laparoscopic power morcellators, despite outraged testimony from dozens of attendees.

The FDA’s Obstetrics and Gynecology Devices panel met July 10-11 to review the use of LPMs in removing uterine fibroids thought to be benign. The practice has been implicated in the spread of undetected uterine cancers, the "upstaging" of a cancerous growth to a fatal stage IV cancer.

In April, the FDA in April issued a Safety Communication discouraging the use of LPMs, estimating that around 1 in 350 women who undergo hysterectomy or myomectomy for presumed fibroids have an unsuspected and difficult-to-diagnose type of uterine cancer called uterine sarcoma. The watchdog agency also requested that manufacturers of LPMs indicated for gynecologic procedures review the products’ labeling to ensure that it contains accurate safety information.

The warning prompted Johnson & Johnson (NYSE:JNJ) and its Ethicon subsidiary to voluntarily suspend sales of its LPMs, but no official recalls have been initiated by regulators.

The 15-member panel offered several suggestions for mitigating the risk of spreading uterine sarcomas in using the morcellators, including an outright ban, stricter product labeling and limiting use in some patient populations.

The panel urged surgeons to take precautions including MRI, radiologic imaging and biopsy and to take patient age and exam findings into account to ensure a fibroid is not cancerous prior to removal. Peri-menopausal and post-menpausal women should definitely not have morcellation, they said. The committee also called for enhanced warnings to surgeons and increased communication to ensure that patients know there is a small but grave risk associated with the use of laparoscopic surgery and the use of LPMs and that other options, such as more invasive abdominal surgery, are available.

Scores of speakers at the public hearing expressed outrage that morcellators are still in use despite evidence of the cancer risk.

Dr. Amy Reed, whose uterine sarcoma was upstaged as a result of morcellation, gave an account of a physician’s personal experience with the practice. Reed asked that the gynecologists on the panel be held criminally liable for defending morcellation.

Reed’s husband, Dr. Keita Sakon, a general surgeon trained at the University of Pennsylvania and cardiothoracic surgeon trained at Brigham Women’s hospital, was 1 of many other speakers who demanded that morcellators be banned. The couple attended the panel with their children in tow.

"I am absolutely astonished by the majority of this panel of gynecological surgeons sitting in front of me who really appear to be thinking that an epidemic of stage IV cancer was just discovered in December of 2013, 20 years after your device has been put on the market," Sakon said. "Who exactly do you think should have been reporting these complications back to the FDA, your patients? Well, we did in December of 2013.

"And now incredibly you all sit here claiming that this is fabricated," he continued. "That there is a shadow of doubt as to what this is. Your specialty’s negligent thinking is intolerable. But the general surgeons on this committee know better. This is a systemic practice. It’s not safe. It’s not responsible. This is a group of surgeons committing industry-wide negligence. Mincing up tumors within a woman’s body is a massive corruption of surgical technique. The mainstay of surgical therapy of sarcomas is to block the section with good margins. That is basic surgery. Gynecologists have corrupted that.

"They’re saying that morcellation is for the benefit of the majority," Sakon added. "I ask you where in our country, where in this society, have we accepted the sacrifice of a minority subset of women for the benefit of the majority? And what is that number we’re going to accept? One in 350? Is it 1 in 1,000? Is it 1 in 500? Especially when it’s avoidable. They say that it should be a matter of women’s choice. Is bad medicine a matter of choice?"

Panel member Dr. Craig Shriver of the Walter Reed Hospital in Bethesda, Md., stressed that all masses should be treated "as cancer until proven otherwise" and reminded the panel of the oath doctors take to do no harm.

"Having been perplexed over the last 2 decades watching the introduction of the laparoscopic power morcellation technique that is totally anathema to these and my core principles as a cancer surgeon, after these 2 days of testimony and data, based on science, I have only more strongly reaffirmed my commitment and belief that there is at present no safe way to offer laparoscopic power morcellation as a part of any minimally invasive surgery. I can clearly state as a member of this advisory committee to the FDA that my position is that the device under consideration, the power morcellator, should have its Class II device status immediately withdrawn and its use in any laparoscopic surgery banned."

Panelist Dr. Carol Brown of the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York defended her specialty’s thinking on fibroids.

"Unfortunately, because fibroids are so common, I don’t think that we can apply the oncological principles about an abnormal growth that we would like to because the result would be hundreds of thousands of women having an unnecessary operation," Brown said. "We do know some things about the epidemiology of the sarcomas.

"It tends to affect older women. We’ve heard here, and it’s been known for a while, that MRI is an imaging modality that can be helpful in diagnosing a benign fibroid. Fibroids tend to be circular, low density, homogeneous, having no abnormal blood vessels, so I do think there are some modalities, patient age and imaging. Also, symptoms and exam findings can be used to have more certainty that we’re dealing with a fibroid. I don’t know that we can say that we have any modality that can tell you it’s leiomyosarcoma, but we did hear some data that a biopsy can diagnose a certain number of leiomyosarcomas," she said.

"So, I just wanted to clarify that for the public and for everyone else, because fibroids are a different histologic, pathologic process," Brown continued. "We’ve heard multiple testimony and it’s definitely clear they do not have to be removed unless there are certain problems that they can be causing, which can include severe bleeding, discomfort, et cetera. If we feel that the only way we can be sure that a woman doesn’t have sarcoma if she has a fibroid is to take out her uterus, you can’t ignore that that would result in hundreds of thousands of operations that are not justified."

Filed Under: Food & Drug Administration (FDA), Gynecological, News Well, Regulatory/Compliance Tagged With: Johnson and Johnson, Obstetrics and Gynecology Devices Advisory Panel

In case you missed it

  • They said it at DeviceTalks Boston
  • Elucid raises $27M for heart disease diagnosis software
  • Summer health technology program brings diverse group of interns to Silicon Valley
  • BioSig expects to raise $3.5M from public offering
  • Haemonetics completes move to new Pennsylvania manufacturing facility
  • Vivera adds two industry veterans to its technology advisory board
  • Abbott Fund grants $750k to education, health equity program
  • Another Medtronic HVAD recall is serious
  • Endologix reports positive results from percutaneous bypass trial
  • NorthStar Medical names new president and chief operating officer
  • Vektor Medical names Rob Krummen as CEO
  • Baxter’s Volara lung therapy system recall is Class I
  • BD voluntarily recalls intraosseous products
  • Bioventus restructures $315M CartiHeal acquisition
  • Intrommune extends scope of Phase 1 trial for peanut-allergy-treating toothpaste
  • How SeaStar’s device calms hyperinflammation — and could prevent lasting damage from COVID cytokine storms
  • Hamilton Medical warns on some ventilators

RSS From Medical Design & Outsourcing

  • They said it at DeviceTalks Boston
    Medtech insiders convened at DeviceTalks Boston 2022 in May to discuss device design, innovation and trends shaping the industry now and in the years and decades ahead. Here are some of the most quotable insights from panelists and speakers at our live event. And make sure to save the date — and save your seat… […]
  • Summer health technology program brings diverse group of interns to Silicon Valley
    Diversity by Doing HealthTech (DxD) is holding a Summer Innovation and Exploration Series for college student interns from underrepresented groups. The series is on its second day today at Fogarty Innovation and Stanford Byers Center for Biodesign — the two organizations that jointly formed and support DxD. The event debuted last year in an online… […]
  • Clippard releases new series of isolation valves
    Clippard (Cincinnati) has Its Clippard NIV Series media isolation valve — a solenoid-operated device using a flexible diaphragm to isolate the actuation mechanism from the fluid path. Media isolation valves find everyday use in a wide variety of applications. Think uses that require precise, repeatable dispensing of media for analytical instrumentation. Clippard says media isolation… […]
  • Another Medtronic HVAD recall is serious
    A year after Medtronic ceded the LVAD market to Abbott, it has yet another Class I recall involving HeartWare Ventricular Assist Device pumps still implanted in patients. The FDA today designated a Medtronic recall involving the HVADs as Class I, the most serious level. It’s the second Class I recall designation for the HVADs this… […]
  • How SeaStar’s device calms hyperinflammation — and could prevent lasting damage from COVID cytokine storms
    SeaStar Medical recently won FDA breakthrough device designation for a new way to treat hyperinflammation with technology that could help fight chronic conditions from COVID-19 infections. The Denver-based medical developer is seeking a humanitarian device exemption for treating children with acute kidney injury (AKI) based on an FDA-funded study, SeaStar President and CEO Eric Schlorff… […]
  • How Avail Medsystems seeks to create a connected OR experience
    Much like a normal Starbucks-goer expects the coffee to taste a certain way at any location, Daniel Hawkins wants that type of experience in the operating room. Hawkins is the CEO of Avail Medsystems, a company developing telemedicine equipment that can connect surgeons, interventional specialists and medical device sales reps. Hawkins and the team at Avail… […]
  • How to leverage technology to drive diversity in clinical studies
    Convenience was the driver, and the traditional clinical trial model had to evolve when it came to a colorectal cancer screening study. The clinical study had 35,000 patients across the U.S. Chuanbo Xu, Freenome Cancer doesn’t discriminate. It’s the second-leading cause of death in the U.S. Early detection is key in treating — and even… […]
  • Medical device licensing pitfalls to avoid
    Prevent costly disputes caused by these common mistakes in patent license agreements. Marcelo Barros, Kathleen Daley, Brian Kacedon and Matthew Ritter, Finnegan Licensing and other technology transfer agreements can be critical for medical device companies that invest significantly into new technology R&D and seek and obtain intellectual property protection for those investments. But if these agreements… […]
  • Tolerance stack-up: Insight into the inner workings of high-density microelectronic medical devices
    Tolerance stack-up is a defining design concept to ensure new products are built efficiently and effectively.  Darren Gilmer, Intricon At a time when the future of micro-miniature medical devices seems unlimited, one fundamental reality remains firmly in place — the sizes and shapes of human anatomy. From blood vessels to ear canals, respiratory passages to… […]
  • Deburring and finishing for beautiful, functional medical devices
    The latest automated cutting tools help medical device manufacturers meet strict specs and high demand. Dave Sawicki, Xebec Increasing demand and advances in technology are driving growth in the medical device industry. Chronic diseases are more prevalent, and the aging population is larger, contributing to the demand for highly regulated Class III medical devices such… […]
  • FDA seeking innovations to move beyond heater-cooler device problems
    The FDA issued a notice today saying that it is working to evaluate new strategies to mitigate infections associated with heater-cooler devices. According to the notice, the administration is collaborating with professional societies, public health partners, heater-cooler manufacturers, and experts on the matter surrounding the heater-cooler devices used during medical and surgical procedures to warm… […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

DeviceTalks Weekly

June 24, 2022
How innovative design, commercial strategy is building Cala Trio’s bioelectronic medicine market
See More >

MEDTECH 100 INDEX

Medtech 100 logo
Market Summary > Current Price
The MedTech 100 is a financial index calculated using the BIG100 companies covered in Medical Design and Outsourcing.
Need Medtech news in a minute?
We Deliver!

MassDevice Enewsletters get you caught up on all the mission critical news you need in med tech. Sign up today.

MDO ad

Footer

MASSDEVICE MEDICAL NETWORK

DeviceTalks
Drug Delivery Business News
Medical Design & Outsourcing
Medical Tubing + Extrusion
Drug Discovery & Development
Pharmaceutical Processing World
MedTech 100 Index
R&D World

Device Talks Webinars, Podcasts, & Discussions

Attend our Monthly Webinars
Listen to our Weekly Podcasts
Join our Device Talks Tuesdays Discussion

MASSDEVICE

Subscribe to MassDevice E-Newsletter
Advertise with us
About
Contact us
Add us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Connect with us on LinkedIn Follow us on YouTube

Copyright © 2022 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Advertise | Privacy Policy | RSS