By Cindy Ivey, Surpass, Inc. (from Surpass’ preclinical blog)
When planning an FDA GLP preclinical study for a medical device or combination product, it is important to consider the strategy for dealing with test and control article characterization early in the process, to ensure appropriate documentation of article build, sterilization, and testing. The following are general principles and commonly asked questions for test and control article characterization in a GLP preclinical study.
Why is characterization required for combination product or medical device test and control articles used in GLP preclinical studies?
- Reconstruction of the article
- Evidence of conformity to outlined specifications
- Demonstrated suitability of the article for the intended use and within the study application
What is characterization for a GLP preclinical study?
Characterization includes the material attributes of the medical device or combination product along with demonstrated functional attributes (often referred to as “stability”). Although they define different properties of the article, characterization and stability are often referred to collectively as “characterization.”
Characterization = Basic Attributes
- Name and descriptors (e.g., medical device dimensions, drug concentration)
- Material composition (e.g., base material, overlay materials, coatings, radiopaque markers)
- If the article is or contains a drug or chemical component, the attributes of the substance must also be outlined (e.g., concentration, distribution, uniformity)
- Packaging
- Sterilization (e.g., method, location, and date of sterilization)
- Testing/inspection (e.g., any inspections or testing of the article attributes to assure that specifications were met)
- Hardware/software components must also be characterized and should be consistent through the study (e.g., avoid installing a new version of software partway through the study)
- Characterization documentation must be provided for each unique lot or batch of articles UNLESS it is a commercially marketed article in its commercial packaging (if it is a commercial article in full commercial packaging, no additional characterization documentation is needed)
- Characterization documentation should include sufficient information to support the article description contained in the study protocol, and traceable to the lots used in the study
Stability = Structural Stability Material or Substance Longevity
- Structural stability testing differs greatly, depending on the article
- Destructive testing of structural strength or stability
- Chemical testing (e.g. elution or absorption rates, leaching in a preservative/suspension)
- Impact of sterilization on materials or substances (e.g. breakdown of components, pre and post-sterilization drug coating analysis)
- Longevity under conditions of use (e.g. breakdown of materials in-vivo (particulation, resorption, device breakage)
- Material or substance longevity in defined storage conditions (basic shelf life / expiration)
- Stability must be documented for each article batch or construct (utilizing the same base materials), but stability testing may often be applied across lots
- Stability can be determined prior to the study, concurrently with the study, or some attributes may be assessed as part of the study (e.g. material breakage or particulation)
- Any stability assessment during the study should be performed equally on the test and control articles even if the article is a commercial article (the only stability information available on a commercial article is the expiration date and FDA has indicated that this is not sufficient for assessing article stability under study conditions)
How can combination product and medical device test article characterization be documented?
- The Sponsor can supply test and control article characterization information for a GLP preclinical study in many different formats and this information will be appended to the Surpass final report:
- Full manufacturing and testing documentation (Design History File, Device History Record, etc.)
- A signed, dated summary of manufacturing and testing, with reference to the appropriate master documents and their location(s) – note: Surpass can provide a template characterization memo for Sponsor convenience
- If the Sponsor is not able to perform testing under GLP compliance, the characterization information should specify the regulations/standards/data integrity steps that were followed, so that this can be noted in the Surpass final report
- The regulations require that characterization be provided for the final study report; however, Surpass recommends that this information be provided early in the process so that we can work together to answer any questions that may be needed for the study
Exact combination product and medical device characterization requirements can vary based on specific test and control article, so work with your trusted preclinical partner Surpass to identify the needs for your upcoming study. We’re here to support you through the entire GLP preclinical study process, contact us today. Silicon Valley 650.938.3675 Greater Twin Cities 715.294.4371 or surpass_inquiries@surpassinc.com.
For more information on GLP studies, be sure to visit www.surpassinc.com and the Surpass preclinical blog.
About the Author: Cindy Ivey, MS, RQAP-GLP, is Director of Regulatory Compliance at Surpass, Inc., a preclinical contract research organization with labs in the Silicon Valley and Greater Twin Cities. Cindy has more than 15 years of experience in quality assurance and regulatory compliance supporting medical devices and combination products. She is an active member of the Society of Quality Assurance (SQA) and has served as the Chair and Vice Chair of the Medical Devices Specialty Section. Cindy also regularly presents on topics around assuring GLP compliance in nonclinical studies of medical devices. Cindy’s Bio
See more about Surpass’ Regulatory/Quality Systems and GLP Studies
The opinions expressed in this blog post are the author’s only and do not necessarily reflect those of MassDevice.com or its employees.
