MassDevice

The Medical Device Business Journal — Medical Device News & Articles | MassDevice

  • Latest News
  • Cardiovascular
  • Orthopedics
  • Wall Street Beat
    • Funding Roundup
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Podcasts
    • MPR: Breakthrough Products Series
  • Resources
    • About MassDevice
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Job Board
    • Leadership in Medtech
    • Manufacturer Search
    • Videos
    • Whitepapers
  • DeviceTalks
You are here: Home / Business/Financial News / Second proxy advisory firm backs Charles River Labs/WuXi merger

Second proxy advisory firm backs Charles River Labs/WuXi merger

July 28, 2010 By MassDevice staff Leave a Comment

CRL, WX logos

Another proxy advisory firm is backing the proposed, $1.6 billion merger between WuXi PharmaTech (Cayman) Inc. (NYSE:WX) and Charles River Laboratories International Inc. (NYSE:CRL), which has drawn opposition from some of CRL’s top investors.

RiskMetrics Group’s ISS Proxy Advisory Services recommended that WuXi shareholders vote for the acquisition of WuXi.

Two other proxy advisory services, Glass Lewis and Proxy Governance, previously recommended that WuXi shareholders approve the transaction, and PROXY Governance Inc. urged Charles River Labs’ shareholders to approve the issuance of stock necessary to complete the acquisition and to postpone a final vote on the deal so that CRL can drum up more proxy support.

It’s the latest move to bolster support for the merger, which has seen at least three of CRL’s institutional investors vigorously oppose the deal. Aiming to counter that opposition, Charles River Labs issued a revised presentation highlighting the benefits of the deal and touted a proxy advisory firm’s support for the merger.

But the PR offensive didn’t sway Jana Partners LLC and managing partner Barry Rosenstein, who fired off a letter to CRL chairman, president and CEO James Foster reiterating his opposition to the deal.

One of the things Charles River Labs emphasized in the investor presentation was the estimated $75 million to $100 million in annual “revenue synergies” the deal is expected to generate. Rosenstein called those predictions “speculative at best," saying they "run counter to industry perceptions of the transaction as well as practical industry dynamics."

"Even assuming such synergies were plausible, given the excessive premium Charles River proposes to pay for Wuxi, this transaction if completed would generate highly inadequate returns," Rosenstein wrote, adding "Charles River’s prior acquisition history and inadequate returns on capital despite significant expenditures over the years are cause for further alarm in evaluating the proposed acquisition, particularly given the significant strategic and integration risks of a WuXi acquisition."

Rosenstein wants Wilmington, Mass.-based Charles River Labs to pursue other ways to increase the company’s value, including a stock buyback or the proverbial "strategic alternatives" — shorthand for seeking an acquirer.

As for Charles River Labs’ move to drum up support by citing favorable reactions from customers to news of the deal, Rosenstein countered with a few citations of his own from investment analysts Raymond James & Associates and Deutsche Bank Securities Inc.:

  • "Raymond James: ‘During our conversations with industry participants, the subject of the Charles River-Wuxi proposed merger often emerged. From the strategic perspective of synergies between discovery services and existing preclinical capabilities, we did not encounter a single individual who agreed with the transaction and/or thought that it would clearly provide a benefit to the resulting entity. In our view, this further validates investor concerns over the merits of the transaction.’"
  • “Deutsche Bank: ‘We view today’s attempt by management to place a medium-term target on revenue synergies as a means of garnering additional support for a transaction that we believe is not broadly favored by shareholders. We would also note that revenue synergies tend to be elusive in nature and particularly hard to capture relative to service based transactions. Therefore, we expect shareholders to discount the revenue synergy potential of the transaction and remain generally against the proposed [WuXi] transaction.'”

Rosenstein’s letter didn’t address PROXY Governance Inc.’s report urging shareholders to approve the issuance of stock necessary to consummate the deal. The proxy advistory firm said it found the strategic arguments behind the deal "compelling" and predicted the long-term results would eclipse any increased value generated by a share repurchasing plan.

Jana Partners was first out of the gate in opposing the deal after it was announced in April. In a June 7 letter to company officials, Rosenstein said he had "serious doubts about the wisdom of pursuing this transaction at this time." In particular, Rosenstein said Charles River’s current low share price would give WuXi a disproportionately large share of the combined companies — equaling a nearly 27 percent stake at CRL’s price of around $32.44 a share.

Charles River Labs was quick to defend the deal. CEO James Foster wrote that the buyout would increase long-term top- and bottom-line growth for CRL, compared with doing nothing or the share repurchasing plan favored by Jana.

Two other institutional investors, Neuberger Berman LLC and Relational Investors LLC, failed to buy into those arguments and also chimed in with their objections.

"Between the stock price reaction and shareholders’ disapproval, it should be clear to management and the board that walking away from this transaction is the right thing to do," Relational principal and managing director Glenn Welling told the Reuters news service. "We hope they get the message."

"Without belaboring the point and put simply, the very rich price being paid for WuXi allows for no margin of error. In our opinion, the proposed transaction with WuXi represents an unacceptable elevation of financial and operational risks to CRL, and therefore, our investment," added Neuberger Berman, according to a regulatory filing.

Citing Charles River’s 2004 buyout of Inveresk for $1.5 billion, which was plagued by integration difficulties and saw CRL sell off significant portions of the acquisition just two years later, the investment firm said it was "perplexed" that CRL would embark on another, massive acquisition.

"The Inveresk transaction was also billed as transformational, promising to accelerate the growth and size of available markets to the company. Instead, the transaction resulted in a $700 MM write-off with growth and consistent profitability remaining elusive in the company’s pre-clinical operations," Neuberger Berman wrote, according to the filing. "CRL’s management needs to demonstrate that its current assets can generate returns well in excess of its cost of capital before being allowed to spend $1.6B of capital. We firmly believe that that the CRL’s shares are significantly undervalued and that a bright future lies ahead for the core businesses of CRL. In our view, a free cash flow financed share repurchase program would demonstrate confidence in CRL’s current asset base and be an excellent use of capital."

Also this week, the Federal Trade Commission asked both companies for more information on the deal, requesting more data on their viral clearance services, cell line characterization services and lot release testing services businesses.

Filed Under: Business/Financial News, Mergers & Acquisitions, News Well, Research & Development Tagged With: Charles River Laboratories International Inc., WuXi PharmaTech (Cayman) Inc.

In case you missed it

  • Caresyntax to acquire Syus; raises $45.6m
  • Nihon Kohden launches new patient monitor
  • Senate confirms Dr. Stephen Hahn to lead FDA
  • Iradimed renews CE mark for MRI-safe patient monitor
  • Flexicare recalls fiber optic laryngoscope blades and handles
  • 3M to sell drug-delivery biz to Altaris Capital Partners for $650m
  • TransEnterix announces reverse split of common stock
  • GI Windows raises $15m Series A
  • ImpediMed lands expanded 510(k) clearance for Sozo
  • Haemonetics opens new Boston headquarters
  • Employees say Intuitive Surgical, J&J, Stryker best places to work in 2020
  • Eitan Group signs service agreement with Integrated Medical Systems
  • Beta Bionics’ bionic pancreas wins breakthrough status from FDA
  • Sanofi backs away from diabetes partnership with Verily
  • FDA clears Cochlear piezoelectric hearing implant
  • Biolase lands 510(k) for dental hygiene laser
  • Mayo Clinic, W.L. Gore team up on stem cell therapy treatments

RSS From Medical Design & Outsourcing

  • Protolabs’ healthcare grant spurs 2 feeding tube inventions
    Digital manufacturer Protolabs (NYSE:PRLB) announced today that MedStar Health (Columbia, Md.) and Cleveland Clinic Innovations are joint winners of the company’s Cool Idea Award: Healthcare Grant. These grants provide in-kind manufacturing services to the support development of medical products to spur innovation in the field. MedStar Health’s gravity-feed syringe holder simplifies the feeding of newborns… […]
  • Nihon Kohden launches new patient monitor
    Nihon Kohden (TYO:6849) announced the U.S. launch of its Life Scope SVM-7200 series vital signs monitor for outpatient facilities and beds that aren’t continuously monitored. The Life Scope SVM-7200 is designed to provide customizable early warning scoring to help clinicians identify patients who are deteriorating or at risk of deterioration. It combines vital signs data with… […]
  • Senate confirms Dr. Stephen Hahn to lead FDA
    The U.S. Senate has confirmed Dr. Stephen Hahn as the next commissioner of the FDA. The vote was 72 to 18, according to a report in the New York Times. Hahn will be the first permanent commissioner of the agency since Dr. Scott Gottlieb resigned in April. President Trump nominated Hahn, the chief medical officer at Houston’s… […]
  • 3M to sell drug-delivery biz to Altaris Capital Partners for $650m
    3M (NYSE:MMM) announced today that it entered into an agreement to sell most of its drug-delivery business to an affiliate of Altaris Capital Partners for approximately $650 million. St. Paul, Minn.-based 3M will retain its transdermal drug delivery components business, according to a news release. The business being divested has annual global sales reaching approximately… […]
  • Lawsuit endangers Sterigenics consent order in Georgia
    A consent order that Sterigenics entered into with the state of Georgia to reduce ethylene oxide (EtO) emissions at its Atlanta medtech sterilization plant may be in jeopardy. A hearing is scheduled today on a lawsuit that accuses the Georgia Environmental Protection Division (EPD) of failing to take public comment before entering the Aug. 7… […]
  • Trelleborg acquires Tritec Seal
    Trelleborg Sealing Solutions said today it has closed on its acquisition of rotary seal manufacturer Tritec Seal, which produces engineered polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) sealing solutions. Trelleborg said the acquisition strengthens its product portfolio while giving the business area access to increased manufacturing capacity. Headquartered in Fenton, Mich., with additional manufacturing in Giddings, Texas, Tritec Seal generated… […]
  • RSNA 2019: 7 radiology innovations you need to know
    Nearly 53,000 people attended the 2019 Radiological Society of North America annual meeting in Chicago last week. And they heard the same acronym over and over again: AI. Exhibitors at the conference touted their artificial-intelligence-enhanced technology at every turn, claiming to make images clearer, sharper, easier to use and powerful enough to help clinicians make… […]
  • Employees say Intuitive Surgical, J&J, Stryker best places to work in 2020
    Intuitive Surgical (NSDQ:ISRG), Johnson & Johnson (NYSE:JNJ) and Stryker (NYSE:SYK) were recently named as Glassdoor’s employees’s choice of Best Places to Work in 2020. Each year, Glassdoor uses feedback that employees have shared on the website over the past year to compile a list of the best places to work in 2020. Employee reviews provide Glassdoor with insights into job and… […]
  • Biolase lands 510(k) for dental hygiene laser
    Biolase (NSDQ:BIOL) this week announced it has received FDA 510(k) clearance for its Epic Hygiene dental laser. The laser system allows dental hygienists to manage non-surgical periodontitis and increase clinical production. It offers a step-by-step clinical protocol with pocket therapy and perio debridement for easy implementation. Get the full story on our sister site, MassDevice. The […]
  • Mayo Clinic, W.L. Gore team up on stem cell therapy treatments
    Mayo Clinic and W. L. Gore & Associates have announced a partnership to develop implantable cell therapies to treat debilitating conditions with no cure. The for-profit company, Avobis Bio, will combine a patient’s own stem cells with bioabsorbable scaffolds to stimulate the healing of perianal fistulas, painful tunneling wounds that affect patients with Crohn’s disease.… […]
  • Toray Industries touts polymer optical fiber
    Toray Industries said today that its Raytela polymer optical fiber provides for high-quality imaging in the minimally invasive medical device market. Raytela can negotiate tight 9mm radius bends, making it useful for devices used in endoscopy, uretroscopy, ophthalmic surgery and other procedures that require smaller devices that can navigate more tortuous paths than previously available,… […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Need Medtech news in a minute?
We Deliver!

MassDevice Enewsletters get you caught up on all the mission critical news you need in med tech. Sign up today.

Popular Posts

  • Report: SEC probes GE Healthcare, Philips, Siemens in Chinese bribery scheme
  • Edwards Lifesciences warns against below-market mini-tender offer Edwards Lifesciences
  • J&J’s Ethicon files ITC complaint against Intuitive Surgical Intuitive Surgical's EndoWrist instruments
  • Auris Health loses motion to move Intuitive Surgical patent suit from Del. to Cali. Johnson & Johnson's Auris, Intuitive Surgical
  • Enable Injections inks deal with Sanofi for drug delivery platform enfuse-enable-injections
Tweets by @MassDevice
MDO ad

MASSDEVICE MEDICAL NETWORK

DeviceTalks
Drug Delivery Business News
Medical Design & Outsourcing
Medical Tubing + Extrusion

MASSDEVICE

Subscribe to MassDevice
Advertise with us
About
Contact us
Add us on FacebookMassDevice Network
Follow us on Twitter@MassDevice
Connect with us on LinkedInLinkedIn
Follow us on YouTube YouTube

Copyright © 2019 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Advertise | Privacy Policy | RSS