Reuters — U.S. mutual funds are placing bigger bets on privately held companies to get a head start finding the next IPO superstar, a strategy that has yielded some dramatic payoffs – and flameouts.
Fast-growing private companies such as Uber Technologies, Pinterest and India’s Flipkart Online Services have attracted billions of dollars in investment from U.S. mutual funds, marking an increase in overall pre-IPO betting over the past few years, analysts and fund managers said. It’s a way to boost their returns and differentiate themselves from faster-growing index funds.
Funds run by Boston-based Fidelity Investments and Baltimore’s T. Rowe Price Group, for example, more than doubled their money with pre-IPO bets on Facebook. And shares of lesser known Zafgen are up 15-fold since the Fidelity Select Biotechnology Portfolio made a pre-IPO investment of $11.2 million in late 2013. Zafgen’s IPO was in June 2014.
“We’re seeing more activity in the private market over the past few years as companies delay their IPOs and stay private longer,” said Katie Reichart, an analyst at fund research firm Morningstar. “It can be a big boost if they get in early. Mutual fund managers don’t want to miss out on that runway to growth.”
A comprehensive, industry-wide picture is difficult to track because mutual fund companies don’t disclose their aggregate private company investments. Disclosures from No. 2 U.S. mutual fund company Fidelity, however, show that some of its biggest funds have more than doubled their pre-IPO investments over the past 2 years.
Of course, some pre-IPO bets have fizzled after companies made their stock market debuts. Twitter was an IPO darling in 2013, helping Morgan Stanley’s $2 billion Small Growth Company Portfolio generate a 62% return for investors that year. The fund invested in Twitter when it was a private company.
Twitter shares have tumbled some 46% since reaching $69 a share in early January 2014. Last year, the Morgan Stanley fund lost 10%, partly because of Twitter’s plunge, while peer funds posted an average return of 2.4%, according to Morningstar. Morgan Stanley declined comment.
Andrew Boyd, who oversees private company investment for Fidelity, said the pre-IPO market has become the IPO market of the past, but it’s only available to investors such as venture capital firms, mutual funds and hedge funds able to put up large amounts of money that once were only available through public markets.
Before, rapid growth might happen after a company’s initial public offering. But now, much of it is happening before the IPO as the pre-IPO financing allows companies more time to mature and get bigger out of the public eye. From companies looking for capital, Boyd said, “We hear that constantly over and over, ‘We’re just not ready for the limelight of [being] a public company. But we need capital!'”
Once Fidelity invests it also holds regular meetings with companies to see if they can make accurate quarterly projections and handle tough questions from skeptical fund managers, Boyd said.
“Finishing school isn’t a bad way to think about it,” he said.
As a result, a company like ride-sharing service Uber may make its stock market debut with a value of more than $50 billion. By contrast, Google’s market capitalization was only about $23 billion when it went public in 2004.
Funds run by Fidelity, T. Rowe Price and Morgan Stanley’s investment management arm have become the most aggressive pre-IPO investors in the fund industry, U.S. regulatory filings show. Fidelity’s $111 billion Contrafund alone had at least $900 million invested in late-stage, pre-IPO companies at the end of April, fund disclosures show. The fund’s pre-IPO investment in photo-sharing website Pinterest, valued at $419 million, was more than its stakes in Home Depot ($356 million) and General Motors ($342.5 million).
Boyd said Fidelity funds typically have less than 1% of their assets invested in pre-IPO companies. Some of the biggest bets, as disclosed by the funds, are on Uber, Pinterest, Intarcia Therapeutics and Space Exploration Technologies.
But Morgan Stanley’s $2 billion Small Company Growth Fund takes a much more aggressive approach. For example, about 5 percent of the fund’s assets are invested in pre-IPO companies.
And one of the single biggest pre-IPO bets, as a percentage of fund assets, is the Morgan Stanley fund’s nearly $50 million investment in Flipkart, India’s biggest e-commerce firm. That’s 3 percent of the fund’s assets, disclosures show.