Jury awards Edwards Lifesciences $70m in CardiAQ Valve spat with Neovasc

May 20, 2016 By Brad Perriello Leave a Comment

A federal jury in Massachusetts yesterday awarded $70 million to Edwards Lifesciences (NYSE:EW) subsidiary CardiAQ Valve Technologies in a patent infringement lawsuit after finding that Neovasc (NSDQ:NVCN) stole trade secrets and breached a non-disclosure agreement.

The lawsuit, filed in June 2014 in the U.S. District Court for Massachusetts, accused Neovasc of using the misappropriated trade secrets to develop its Tiara transcatheter mitral valve replacement. Edwards inherited the lawsuit when it acquired CardiAQ Valve for $400 million in August 2014.

Neovasc approached CardiAQ Valve in June 2009 and offered to help it develop the TMVI device, according to the lawsuit. The companies signed a non-disclosure agreement and worked together on the replacement heart valve until February 2010, the lawsuit claims.

But in mid-2009, CardiAQ valve alleged, Neovasc breached their NDO by using the CardiAQ Valve technology as the basis for the Tiara device, and filing patent applications covering the ideas.

The jury found Neovasc guilty of breach of contract, but did not award any damages, according to court documents. The panel found that Neovasc misappropriated 3 of the 6 trade secrets claimed in the suit, awarding $70 million to CardiAQ Valve. The jury also found that Neovasc unfair or deceptive trade practices and that CardiAQ Valve co-founder, president & COO Brent Ratz (now an R&D VP for Edwards’ TMVR program) and co-founder Dr. Arshad Quadri (the “AQ” in CardiAQ) contributed to the conception of the CardiAQ Valve patent, according to the documents.

“Through many years of dedicated work with Dr. Quadri, we were able to develop an extensive base of knowledge, make important advancements and create the CardiAQ transcatheter mitral valve to help patients in need who are not well-served by therapies available today,” Ratz said in prepared remarks. “We are proud of this foundational work and grateful that the jury recognized these contributions to the developing field of transcatheter mitral valve replacement.”

Edwards said Judge Allison Burroughs will rule later on the jury’s determination of Neovasc’s unfair or deceptive acts and Quadri’s and Ratz’s contributions to the patent.

“Regrettably, the jury trial phase of this lawsuit was not resolved to our satisfaction. We will be exploring our options regarding post-trial motions in the trial court and, potentially, the appellate process,” Neovasc CEO Alexei Marko said in a press release. “As we have throughout this process, we will remain diligent in our company’s purpose to advance our cardiovascular products to improve patient care by addressing two significant unmet structural heart diseases, mitral regurgitation and refractory angina.”

NVCN shares closed down -7.1% at $1.84 apiece yesterday.

Registration is Open for DeviceTalks Boston

Registration is open for DeviceTalks Boston! Join us on June 5-6, 2019, as we explore the trends and technology that are shaping the future of the medical device industry.

REGISTER NOW

Medical device cybersecurity: It’s time to get real
Medical device makers, regulators and healthcare delivery organizations are increasingly working together to strengthen cybersecurity. But are they doing enough? Almost no one in the medtech industry disputes the vulnerability posed by cyberattacks. How to go about boosting security is another matter – one on which those stakeholders have recently stepped up their collaboration. One… […]
Can a lifetime guarantee boost value-based care?
Swiss orthopedics company Medacta International and Geisinger Health System have said they will pilot a lifetime guarantee program for knee replacement surgeries. The program will cover full costs for screened Geisinger Health Plan members who receive knee replacement surgery while also ensuring reimbursement for any associated future care the patients may incur throughout their lifetimes.… […]
Compounding Solutions launches new tie-layer resin
Compounding Solutions (Lewiston, Maine) recently announced that it has launched a new tie-layer resin for the medical device industry. ReZilok Rx is meant for the manufacturing of multilayer co-extruded medical films and catheter tubing, the company said in a February announcement. Compounding Solutions’ R&D team developed ReZilok Rx as a linear low-density polyethylene grafted with… […]
GI Dynamics touts results of U.K. study
GI Dynamics (ASX:GID) said a retrospective study of its EndoBarrier device for patients with type 2 diabetes and obesity shows a significant reduction in HbA1c, weight, liver fat and cardiovascular disease (CVD) risks as well as a reduction in the need for insulin in some patients. The EndoBarrier device is a plastic gut sleeve designed… […]
Think Surgical, United Orthopedic join forces for global sales
Think Surgical and United Orthopedic have announced a global joint marketing agreement of Think’s Active robotic system and United’s U2 knee system. Think’s Active robotic system consists of a 3D pre-surgical planning workstation and its computer-assisted Active robot. Its use in total knee arthroplasty is the subject of an FDA investigational device exemption study, with… […]
FDA ramps up scrutiny of materials in medical devices
The FDA said today it has begun more closely scrutinizing the roles of certain materials associated with harm to patients who have breast implants, nitinol-containing devices, metal-on-metal hip implants and devices made from animal-derived substances. It’s the latest in a series of statements the agency has issued following increasingly harsh public criticism of its efforts… […]
AxioMed receives CE Mark approval for Cervical Freedom
AxioMed has received CE Mark approval for its viscoelastic disc replacement device. The Cervical Freedom’s total disc replacement is now eligible for commercialization in the European, Asian, Latin American and Australian markets and where it has already been TGA approved. AxioMed’s Freedom Cervical disc responds to loading and moves in three dimensions like the human… […]
10 orthopedic products from AAOS 2019 you need to know
The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) annual meeting in Las Vegas is abuzz about robotics, according to industry analysts from SVB Leerink. While the SVB Leerink analysts termed Stryker’s (NYSE:SYK) Mako platform “best-in-class,” robotically assisted orthopedic surgery is an expanding category. Other major orthopedics companies are using this week’s AAOS meeting to introduce new… […]
Webinar: Here’s how you create better healthcare experiences through human-centered design
Wednesday, April 17, 2019 2 p.m. Eastern time / 11 a.m. Pacific time The greatest challenges in healthcare are at the human level. Diet, fitness, medication adherence and regular check-ups can all be influenced by our personal relationships. While today’s technology can impede these human-to-human interactions, following a human-centered approach gives organizations the power to… […]
Orthopaedic Implant Co. enters sports medicine market with new suture anchor
The Orthopaedic Implant Company (“OIC”) said it has launched a 5.5mm PEEK suture anchor system for orthopedic surgery. The OIC 5.5mm suture anchor accommodates up to three #2 sutures of any brand, resulting in an implant that offers flexibility, at a cost-effective price, according to the Reno, Nev.-based company. The anchors are made of biocompatible… […]
Oberd launches AI-assisted tech for gathering outcome data
Patient-reported outcomes vendor Oberd said it has launched software designed to reduce a patient’s time in completing outcomes surveys for orthopedic procedures. Patient-reported outcomes can help quantify the value of a healthcare provider’s services. Columbia, Mo.-based Oberd’s computer-adaptive test (CAT) software has been developed and validated for all of the outcomes surveys approved by the… […]