Johnson & Johnson’s Ethicon loses $35m pelvic mesh lawsuit

March 12, 2018 By Brad Perriello Leave a Comment

An Indiana jury hit Johnson & Johnson (NYSE:JNJ) subsidiary Ethicon with a $35 million verdict in a product liability lawsuit brought over its Prolift pelvic mesh.

Barbara Kaiser and her husband Anton Kaiser sued Ethicon in March 2012, after learning that the Prolift mesh her doctor implanted in 2009 to treat her pelvic organ prolapse might be causing her low pelvic pain.

The lawsuit accused J&J and Ethicon of concealing the problems with Prolift, which allegedly include high failure, injury, and complication rates and “frequent and often debilitating re-operations,” according to the Kaiser’s complaint. Prolift “caused severe and irreversible injuries, conditions, and damage to a significant number of women, including plaintiff,” according to the complaint.

“Defendants have consistently underreported and withheld information about their Prolift’s propensity to fail and cause injury and complications, and have misrepresented the efficacy and safety of the products through various means and media, actively and intentionally misleading the medical community, patients, and the public at large,” the Kaisers alleged. “Defendants actively and intentionally misled and continue to mislead the public, including the medical community, health care providers, and patients, into believing their Prolift is safe and effective, leading to the prescription for, and implantation of, their Prolift into plaintiff, Barbara Kaiser, and numerous other women.”

The U.S. District Court for Northern Indiana jury March 8 awarded Barbara Kaiser $10 million in damages and $25 million in punitive damages but gave nothing to Anton Kaiser, according to court documents.

“Ethicon defended an indefensible product and the jury stood up for Barbara Kaiser,” her attorney, Thomas Plouff, told Scotland’s Sunday Post. “They were asked to send a message to Ethicon to deter future wrongdoing, and they did.”

Johnson & Johnson plans to appeal the verdict, spokeswoman Mindy Tinsley told MassDevice.com via email, “as we believe it contradicts the evidence that the product was properly designed and that the company appropriately informed surgeons of pertinent complications.”

“Pelvic organ prolapse is a serious and debilitating condition with limited treatment options. Scientists from around the world who have conducted and reviewed independent research on pelvic mesh agree it is an important treatment option for some women. All surgeries to treat pelvic organ prolapse have risks. While we empathize with those who have experienced complications, many women with pelvic mesh see an improvement in their day to day lives,” Tinsley told us. “Ethicon stands by, and will continue to defend, our pelvic mesh products in litigation.”

See the next generation of leaders at DeviceTalks Minnesota!

On June 4-5, DeviceTalks is taking over the Twin Cities medtech industry with one of the most anticipated conferences of the spring, bringing you the best and brightest minds in the industry.

KEYNOTE SPEAKERS

Heidi Dohse: Sr. Program Manager, Healthcare, Google, Founder, Tour de Heart Foundation, Acessa Health Inc. Michael J. Pederson: Senior Vice President, Cardiac Arrhythmias and Heart Failure Division, Abbott Hon. Melvin Carter: Mayor, Saint Paul Tim Philips: Compliance Officer, FDA’s Office of Medical Device and Radiological Health Operations Dr. Myriam J. Curet, MD, FACS: Chief Medical Officer, Intuitive Surgical

Take a look at our incredible line up of speakers and join us now.

Use the code "KEYNOTE" to save 15% on the cost of registration.

REGISTER TODAY

4 ways medtech contractors are evolving (and why)
The present and near future for medtech contractors will rely on specific strategies such as tiered partnerships and consolidation, an emphasis on speed, and owning therapeutic and technology spaces. Andrew Potter, Bonifacio Consulting Services, and Christopher Delporte In the first article in this series, we examined some of the important trends during the last 10–15 years […]
Minnesota’s Medical Alley has a big presence at EuroPCR
The Medical Alley Association in Minnesota is touting the major presence that companies and organizations from the state will have at this year’s EuroPCR, which is being held this week in Paris. The event — the European Association of Percutaneous Cardiovascular Interventions’ annual meeting — is May 22–25 at the Palais des Congrès and is expected to […]
Will FDA turn to neuroscience-based human factors research?
There is a new wind blowing in medical technology — one that many believe is overdue: an overhaul of human factors. At the recent Patient Safety Initiative, Charles Murphy, Chief Patient Safety Officer at the Inova Heart and Vascular Institute, called out human factors as one of the key factors he believed needed to be […]
High-volume manufacturing: Essential points to consider before you scale up
High-volume manufacturing typically involves the introduction of automation into the medical device fabrication and assembly process. A number of benefits usually follow: repeatability, heightened quality and lower (and more predictable) long-term costs of operation. Download the B. Braun Medical white paper. The post High-volume manufacturing: Essential points to consider before you scale up appeared first […]
C&K launches autoclave-safe medical switch product line
C&K announced that it has launched its medical switch product line of autoclave-safe switches. The new medical switches are designed to meet industry sterilization standards that protect patients from risks that comes from reusable tools. Sterilization helps prevent contamination from fluid and contagion ingress. “Medical device engineers are creating the applications that people entrust to […]
Can Minnesota become a healthcare innovation hub?
Minnesota has the institutions and the talent to transform healthcare in the U.S. The question is whether the money will follow. RxFunction makes wearable devices called “Walkasins” that help people with chronic health conditions prevent falls that can lead to serious injury. It took eight painstaking years, though, before the Eden Prairie, Minn.-based startup secured […]
Medtech Association to host inaugural MedTechIDEAS Summit
The Medtech Association is hosting its inaugural MedTechIDEAS Summit on May 31 in Skaneateles Falls, N.Y. The event will take place at 11 a.m. until 5:30 p.m. at the Lodge at Welch Allyn. The MedTechIDEAS Summit is a quarterly conference series that presents a “big idea” in healthcare from an industry thought leaders while delivering […]
Triton to sell Aventics company to Emerson
Triton recently announced that it plants to sell its Aventics pneumatics company to Emerson. The financial details of the deal were not disclosed. Emerson and Triton recently came to an agreement and the transaction is in progress, starting with the regulatory approval process that is currently underway. Aventics serves the life sciences industry by providing […]
Grayhill launches Touch Encoder Development Kit
Grayhill recently launched its Touch Encoder Development Kit that gives product development engineers simplified designs for medical applications. The new development kit features tap, swipe and turn functions that gives designers the opportunity to replace traditional user-input devices. Using a tablet development app, product development engineers can personalize multi-touch gestures, create images and customize the […]
Webinar: How to balance regulations and performance with your medical device design
Wednesday, June 20, 2018 2 p.m. Eastern time / 11 a.m. Pacific time Creating a medical device that meets both regulatory compliance and performance requirements takes careful planning. You also need to understand the most efficient path to market commercialization in order to stay within budget and on schedule. This is no simple […]
Diversified Plastics expands sales engineer and technical support team
Diversified Plastics (Minneapolis) recently announced that it has added three new sales engineer and technical support members to its team. Raymond Schenk has joined Diversified Plastics as senior sales engineer. He has over 24 years of experience in the plastic industries and will be responsible for the western territories of the company. Prior to joining the […]