MassDevice

The Medical Device Business Journal — Medical Device News & Articles | MassDevice

  • MassDevice Today
    • Cardiovascular
    • Clinical Trials
    • Legal News
    • Orthopedics
    • Regulatory/Compliance
  • Wall Street Beat
    • Funding Roundup
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • More MedTech
    • Cosmetic/Aesthetic
    • Diabetes
    • Dialysis
    • Distribution
    • Imaging
    • Otolaryngology Ear, Nose & Throat
    • Pharma
    • Respiratory
    • Wound Care
  • Blog
  • DeviceTalks Podcasts
  • Resources
    • About MassDevice
    • Job Board
    • Leadership in Medtech
    • Manufacturer Search
    • White Papers
  • DeviceTalks
Home » Intuitive Surgical sued over heart stabilizer patent

Intuitive Surgical sued over heart stabilizer patent

October 10, 2012 By MassDevice staff Leave a Comment

Share
Intuitive Surgical

Intuitive Surgical‘s(NSDQ:ISRG) da Vinci surgical robot infringes at least 1 claim of a patent owned by Alisanos LLC, according to a lawsuit.

Alisanos, a Longview, Texas-based intellectual property development and licensing company, accused Intuitive of learning the ins and outs of its patent for the so-called "’573 patent, or "Through-Port Heart Stabilization System," when they began negotiation over a possible partnership in November 2000 – even as Alisanos’ corporate predecessor, Medcanica/POPCAB, was seeking the patent, according to court documents. A feature of Intuitive’s flagship da Vinci devices called the EndoWrist Stabilizer allegedly violates the patent, Alisanos claimed.

"After gaining knowledge of Medcanica/POPCAB’s proprietary information, Intuitive claimed to be interested in forming a ‘product development relationship’ with Medcanica/POPCAB whereby Medcanica/POPCAB would adapt its existing inventions (which shortly thereafter formed the basis of the ’573 patent application) to be used within Intuitive’s ‘ISI Robotic Surgical System,’" according to the documents.

But Intuitive allegedly proved gunshy and had backed out of the deal by the spring of 2001a, according to the documents, and by 2003 Medcanica/POPCAB was out of cash and eventually dissolved.

"Without Intuitive or a replacement partner, there was no business relationship to help finance the research and product development. Likewise, the once promising upstarts were without ready-access to distribution and marketing channels, even if product development could resume," according to documents filed in the U.S. District Court for Southern Florida.

Alisanos also alleged that Intuitive learned more about the patent from a company called ICAP Ocean Tomo when Alisanos was "exploring different business options and was working with ICAP Ocean Tomo to explore ways to monetize Medcanica LLC’s intellectual property," according to the documents.

"ICAP Ocean Tomo contacted Intuitive and informed it that ICAP Ocean Tomo may be able to acquire or otherwise make available for purchase Medcanica, LLC’s intellectual property – including the ’573 patent," according to the lawsuit. "Plaintiff contends that this contact by ICAP Ocean Tomo further informed Intuitive of the ’573 patent and put Intuitive on notice that the accused devices infringed the ’573 patent. With Intuitive’s knowledge of the ’573 patent, Intuitive’s infringement was and continues to be objectively reckless."

Alisanos wants a jury trial, judgments of infringement and willful infringement (which would treble any damages awarded), pre- & post-judgment interest and legal fees.

With more than 30 speakers, 25 panels and 4 tracks, you can't miss DeviceTalks Minnesota

textadimage On June 4-5, DeviceTalks Minnesota is taking over the Twin Cities medtech industry with one of the most anticipated conferences of the spring.

Join leaders from 3M, Abbott, Bigfoot Biomedical, Boston Scientific, Cardionomic, CMF Solutions, Cyient, Google Mayo Clinic, Medical Alley, Medtronic, NxThera, Opus College, Relievant Medsystems, University of Minnesota, Star Tribune, Smith & Nephew, Spry Health, Zimmer Biomet and many more when you register today.

Use the code "DTWeb" to save 15% on the cost of registration. 

REGISTER TODAY

Filed Under: Legal News, News Well, Patent Infringement, Robotics Tagged With: Alisanos LLC, Intuitive Surgical

In case you missed it

  • Brainlab releases VersaHD high-res planning algorithm
  • Varian wins FDA nod for Calypso anchored beacon transponder for SBRT therapy
  • Nephros releases preliminary Q1 earnings, raises $3m
  • Olympus inks endoscope image sharing deal with InterSystems
  • FDA approves IDE trial for Urotronic’s drug-coated balloon
  • FDA approves Angel Medical System’s AngelMed Guardian cardiac monitor
  • Curetis launches diagnostic cartridge for urinary tract infection
  • Hologic touts study comparing NovaSure to Minerva’s endometrial ablation device
  • How Minnesota got a Pediatric Device Innovation Consortium
  • 5 medtech stories we missed this week: April 20, 2018
  • FDA OKs Opus breast implant line from Sientra
  • Sollis lands $50m for long-acting pain-relief drug
  • Chinese investor group acquires Esaote
  • GE Healthcare’s sales, profits up in Q1
  • Qiagen wins FDA nod for point-of-care PartoSure test
  • Valeritas taps Glooko’s data management platform for next-gen insulin delivery device
  • Arthrosurface wins FDA nod for OVOMotion shoulder arthroplasty system

RSS From Medical Design & Outsourcing

  • How Minnesota got a Pediatric Device Innovation Consortium
    FDA funds a handful of pediatric device innovation groups around the United States. But Dr. Gwenyth Fischer, director of The Pediatric Device Innovation Consortium at the University of Minnesota, thinks there’s something that sets the seven-year-old group apart. The Minnesota group, Fischer said, is focused not only on funding but on getting doctors and other academics […]
  • Zeiss adds Xradia Context microCT to X-ray portfolio
    Zeiss has launched its new X-ray imaging instrument the Xradia Context microCT, which is a large field-of-view, non-destructive 3D X-ray microcomputed tomography system. The new Zeiss system is a tomographic imaging solution for 3D characterization and inspection needs for a variety of applications. The system allows users to easily adjust the system to enable imaging […]
  • Medtech stories we missed this week: April 20, 2018
    From CHF Solutions’ new Italian distribution deal to Masimo’s CE Mark approval, here are five medtech stories we missed this week but thought were still worth mentioning. 1. CHF Solutions signs Italian distribution deal CHF Solutions announced in an April 17 press release that it has signed a new distribution agreement with TRX Italy to distribute […]
  • FDA OKs Opus breast implant line from Sientra, with Lubrizol manufacturing
    The FDA this week granted a pre-market approval supplement to Sientra (NSDQ:SIEN) for its Opus line of silicone breast implants. The implants are made in Wisconsin by Lubrizol LifeSciences subsidiary Vesta, which inked a contract manufacturing deal with Sientra back in August 2016. Sales of Sientra’s silicone breast implants ground to a halt in the autumn of 2015, when […]
  • Icon and Intel forge partnership for pharmaceutical analytics platform for clinical trials
    Icon and Intel have struck an deal that allows Icon to offer the Intel Pharma Analytics Platform in clinical trials. The financial details of the deal were not disclosed. The Intel platform is an edge-to-cloud artificial intelligence platform that allows clinical data to be remotely monitored while it continuously captures data for study participants who […]
  • OCTANe announces partnership with Small Cap Nation
    Orange County, Calif.–based life sciences accelerator organization OCTANe recently announced a strategic partnership with Small Cap Nation (SCN), a New York City–based financial media content distribution platform. SCN delivers breaking, on-demand news and information related to the domestic and international small-cap sector. It recently opened a Silicon Valley office. “This partnership will open an important source of capital […]
  • Cadence snapped up by private equity firm Kohlberg & Co.
    Officials at high-precision components and finished devices maker Cadence are selling the Staunton, Va.–based company to private equity outfit Kohlberg & Co. Financial terms of the definitive agreement, announced yesterday, were not disclosed. Cadence makes components and devices for advanced surgical and specialty industrial applications. Cadence CEO Alan Connor will continue to lead the company, and […]
  • Turns out graphene can fight bacteria on implants
    Graphene flakes that are arranged like spikes can kill bacteria and stop infections during implant surgery procedures, according to new research from Chalmers University of Technology in Göteborg, Sweden. Bacteria moves around the body in fluids like blood looking for an area to stick to. Once they find a place, the bacteria starts to grow […]
  • How augmented reality and virtual reality devices are boosting medicine
    Augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) devices have immense disruptive potential, with the capacity to change how the healthcare industry delivers patient care and provider training. These technologies are helping to take medicine outside clinical spaces and will present a wide range of opportunities for innovators as professionals continue to adapt. Tim Jennings,  Custom […]
  • TT Electonics wraps up acquisition of Stadium Group
    TT Electronics (Woking, U.K.) said today that it has completed its purchase of Stadium Group, a Reading, U.K.–based supplier of connectivity products and services, power supplies, human-machine interface (HMI) and electronic assemblies. Financial terms of the deal were not disclosed. Stadium products are used in applications including medical equipment, smart home, industrial robotics and aircraft cabin controls […]
  • Excelitas Technologies touts OmniCure at InPrint Industrial Inkjet Conference
    Excelitas Technologies is touting its OmniCure OV LED curing solutions at this year’s InPrint Industrial Inkjet Conference at The Palmer House Hilton in Chicago, May 1-2. The company will showcase its new OmniCure AC8-HD (high dose) series of UV LED curing systems that offer higher optical power and enhanced performance in the same air-cooled mechanical […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Need Medtech news in a minute?
We Deliver!

MassDevice Enewsletters get you caught up on all the mission critical news you need in med tech. Sign up today.

Tweets by @MassDevice

MASSDEVICE MEDICAL NETWORK

DeviceTalks
Drug Delivery Business News
Medical Design & Outsourcing

MASSDEVICE

Subscribe to MassDevice
Advertise with us
About
Contact us
Privacy
Add us on FacebookMassDevice Network
Follow us on Twitter@MassDevice
Connect with us on LinkedInLinkedIn
Connect with us on Google PlusGoogle+

Copyright © 2018 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Advertise | Privacy Policy