German court hands down another mixed decision in TAVR spat between Boston Scientific, Edwards Lifesciences

March 9, 2017 By Brad Perriello Leave a Comment

A German court issued a mixed decision in the international battle over transcatheter aortic valve replacement patents between Edwards Lifesciences (NYSE:EW) and Boston Scientific (NYSE:BSX), less than a week after a U.K. patent court handed down a similar TAVR decision.

Boston Scientific fired the 1st shot late last year in Germany with a lawsuit against Edwards, alleging that the next-generation Sapien 3 infringes claims covering the outer sealing skirt of Boston’s Lotus valve. Edwards claims that the Boston patent issued after Edwards launched the Sapien 3 valve in Europe and has leveled its own suits against its rival and subsidiary Sadra Medical; Boston Scientific filed counterclaims of its own in Germany and the U.K., where the Patents Court found 1 of its patents invalid but upheld another and ruled that Edwards infringes it.

Today the companies said that the German District Court of Düsseldorf found that the Edwards Sapien 3 TAVR infringes a pair of patents covering the outer seals of Boston’s Lotus valve. The Düsseldorf court also ruled that Boston Scientific did not infringe an Edwards patent, but did infringe a different TAVR patent (although Marlborough, Mass.-based Boston said it expects the European Patent Office to revoke that patent).

“We will continue to protect our intellectual property to ensure we can continue to bring forward innovative technologies that make a meaningful difference in the lives of patients,” Boston Scientific general counsel Tim Pratt said in prepared remarks. “We are pleased with the progress we are making with litigation in Europe, and believe the strength of our intellectual property will also be upheld in U.S. cases involving the same patents.”

For its part, Edwards pledged to appeal the ruling, as it did with the U.K. patent court decision, adding that it “believes that the company will ultimately prevail.”

Boston Scientific last month recalled all Lotus devices “due to reports of premature release of a pin connecting the Lotus Valve to the delivery system.”

LiveNova wins FDA clearance for mitral annuloplasty ring
LivaNova recently announced that it has received FDA 510(k) clearance for its Memo 4D semi-rigid mitral annuloplasty ring. Memo 4D is the next generation of devices in the company’s Memo device family. It comes in a wide range of ring sizes from 24 to 42mm, allowing for more patients with mitral regurgitation to get treatment. […]
5 things medtech manufacturing executives learned from their dads
Sometimes working for your dad seems like destiny, but taking over the family business wasn’t always the plan. There are many second- and third-generation medtech manufacturers run by executives following in their dads’ footsteps. Here’s what they learned. Eric Crainich, president and owner of Design Standards (Charlestown, N.H.), was told from a young age that […]
These nanorobots clear bacteria and toxins from blood
Researchers at the University of California at San Diego have created tiny ultrasound-powered nanorobots that are designed to swim through blood and remove bacteria and toxins. The UCSD researchers built the nanorobots using gold nanowires coated with a hybrid of platelet and red blood cell membranes. The hybrid coating meant the nanorobots can perform two […]
Mack Molding investing millions into N.C., Vermont facilities
Mack Molding (Arlington, Vt.) recently announced that it is hiring and investing millions of dollars at its Statesville, N.C. facility and its three Vermont locations. “The resurgence of manufacturing in the United States is strong, and Mack has been aggressive in ensuring we are well-positioned to seize the opportunity presented to us,” Jeff Somple, Mack’s president, […]
Medtech stories we missed this week: June 15, 2018
From Cytosorbents opening a new U.S. manufacturing facility to DyAnsys received FDA clearance for a wearable to treat opioid withdrawals, here are seven medtech stories we missed this week but thought were still worth mentioning. 1. Cytosorbents opens new U.S. manufacturing facility CytoSorbents announced in a June 12 press release that it has opened a new […]
Keystone Electronics touts UL recognized, quick-fit terminals
Keystone Electronics is touting its UL recognized, male and female, PCB quick-fit terminals, as well as its male rivet mount quick-fit terminals. The quick-fit terminals are designed to withstand repeated mating cycles. The PCB mountable terminals have a Sturdi-Mount design that increases its mounting strength and stability by maintaining the terminal’s perpendicularity to PCBs during […]
Mean Well expands high-performance medical power supply line
Mean Well recently announced that it has extended its MSP line up to 1000 W with its MSP-1000 series. The MSP-1000 series shares the same mechanism of Mean Well’s MSP-600 series, according to the Fremont, Calif.–based company. The shared mechanism means that customers are able to replace a 600 W power supply with a 1000 W […]
GW Plastics increases scientific molding process development capabilities
GW Plastics recently announced that it has expanded and upgraded its process development and training center in its Royalton, Vt. location. The upgrade allows the facility to develop and debug entire manufacturing cells in a dedicated non-production facility. The expansion takes place during the company’s 20th anniversary of the process development center that received RJG […]
Adhesives and medical devices: How to make sure things don’t go wrong
Too often the adhesive selection for a medical device is left to the end of a project. It doesn’t help that there are so many adhesives as to make the choice overwhelming. With so many potential negative outcomes, here are tips on making the right choice. Tony Kaufman and Del R. Lawson, Critical and Chronic Care […]
Traco Power announces 3.5 W medical dc-dc converters
Traco Power recently announced the release of their TIM 3.5 and TIM 3.5SM families of medical 3.5 W DC/DC converters — in compact DIP 16 or SMD 16 package that measures only 0.95 x 0.57 x 0.40 in. The new converters are ideal for healthcare products where small size is required and parts are applied […]
Here’s how FDA officials think you can legally promote off-label device, drug uses
The FDA has issued final guidance clarifying what it considers permissible off-label information for device makers and drug companies to convey to potential customers. A pair of guidance documents outlines how medtech and pharmaceutical companies can explain to payors and hospitals how their products can affect outcomes and potentially save money, beyond what the products’ indication with the […]