MassDevice

The Medical Device Business Journal — Medical Device News & Articles | MassDevice

  • Latest News
  • Cardiovascular
  • Orthopedics
  • Wall Street Beat
    • Funding Roundup
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Podcasts
    • MPR: Breakthrough Products Series
  • Resources
    • About MassDevice
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Job Board
    • Leadership in Medtech
    • Manufacturer Search
    • Videos
    • Whitepapers
  • DeviceTalks
You are here: Home / Legal News / Legal win leaves Vascular Solutions CEO Root weary of the corner office

Legal win leaves Vascular Solutions CEO Root weary of the corner office

October 24, 2016 By Fink Densford Leave a Comment

Howard Root

Vascular Solutions CEO Howard Root

After being acquitted of federal felony charges for off-label marketing and a prosecution that spanned 5 years, Vascular Solutions (NSDQ:VASC) CEO Howard Root said he’s still recovering from the strain of battling federal prosecutors.

TJSmith, a lawyer, said if it wasn’t for his previous life in the field of law he would have cracked under the pressure of the investigation. And even with that training, the experience made him question staying in the industry.

“I don’t want to do this job anymore. I feel like I’m getting pushed out. I was a lawyer, I started a medical device company. I create jobs, I create medical devices, I try to save lives, and I’ve had good fortune to be successful. And they want to throw me in prison because a sales rep said the wrong word,” Root told MassDevice.com last week after appearing on a panel at the annual AdvaMed conference in Minneapolis. “Why would I do this? I’m not doing it for the money. I’m not doing it for the fame. All I’m doing it for is to make medical devices, and I have this sort of risk. Something’s got to change or no one is going to be doing this for the right reason.”

The company’s employees faced intense scrutiny from the U.S. Justice Dept. that changed the lives of many at Vascular Solutions, Root said during the panel interview, and won’t be the last to face DoJ charges.

“Fifty percent of public commercial medical device companies have at least 1 ongoing government investigation and today, all of those are criminal,” he explained. “Look at the person next to you. Does that person look like a criminal? If not, it’s you. Fifty percent are subject to criminal indictment.”

Vascular Solutions faced charges in an off-label promotion scheme for its now-discontinued Vari-Lase varicose vein treatment, specifically a “Short Kit” version designed for treating perforator veins. Root said the charges stemmed from a disgruntled ex-sales rep, who filed a whistleblower case that was picked up by federal prosecutors.

Root said the device only ever brought in just over $500,000, making up only around 0.01% of total sales, and that it had a general indication for treating varicose veins, which included perforator veins. Despite the general indication, Root said he personally instructed sales reps to not offer or sell the device for any off-label indications.

Even though the company fully cooperated with the government, Root said his employees were over-scrutinized by investigators, and mishandled in a fashion that made him question the motivation of the state.

“Prosecutors will call your employees’ testimony a line of shit and warn that things will get much worse for you if you don’t change your testimony. That followed up with calling another employee a ‘poor effer,’ using the actual word, ‘who needs to return on bended knee to fix his testimony,'” Root said. “Then the worst 1, said to my female employee, ‘If you do not deliver us with the answers we want to hear today, it should be made known that we have power to withhold rights and privileges provided to your natural born son.’ I remind you, these are federal prosecutors. Federal agents on a charge of off-label promotion of a product that made up 0.1% of our sales and never harmed a single patient. This is where they are going when they don’t get their way.”

And intrusive questioning and harassment weren’t the only loss – the case also came with a $25 million legal bill.

“What does it take to survive a trial, before you get to the trial? What is it going to take?” Root said. “Start with $25 million to pay 14 law firms and 121 lawyers. That’s just to get everyone covered. Maybe we had wasted $5 million to $10 million, but it’s an expensive process. That’s the easiest thing to do.”

The Justice Dept. alleged that the company designed and pushed the Vari-Lase short kit after an unidentified competitor won FDA clearance for a radiofrequency ablation device to treat the same veins. Prosecutors claimded that the Vari-Lase device was being pushed for indications for perforator veins, for which it was denied an extended 510(k) in 2007.

At trial, however, the FDA expert called by the prosecution admitted that the device’s general indication covered perforator veins, Root said.

“He just admitted that our general indication included perforator veins. This is an off-label prosecution on an on-label use,” he told us after his panel appearance. “I was being charged in violation of a non-binding FDA guidance document. That’s how crazy this trial got to be.”

A federal jury in February acquitted Vascular Solutions, without the defense having to call a single witness, Root said. Despite the positive outcome, cases like this are having a major impact on the industry, he added, and need to be addressed to keep medtech headed in the right direction.

“This is important for our industry. We do a lot of great things. People with heart attack don’t die as often as they used to. Twenty-five percent in ’78, 5% now. Stroke’s down 59% and we’re doing even more today,” Root said. “I think you need to be prepared, because this is coming after a lot of people. Not just me.”

Filed Under: Legal News Tagged With: vascularsolutions

In case you missed it

  • W.L. Gore officials think they can spur insulin delivery system innovation
  • EPA moves closer to stricter regulations on medtech ethylene oxide sterilization
  • 3DBio Therapeutics wins FDA rare pediatric disease designation for outer ear reconstruction
  • CryoLife wins CE Mark for E-nya thoracic stent graft
  • Edwards projects $5 billion in sales for 2020
  • SPR Therapeutics announces 1000th placement of nerve stimulation device
  • The best places to work for medtech sales reps
  • DePuy Synthes issues urgent field safety notice for USS II Polyaxial 3D heads
  • Haemonetics (HAE) launches SafeTrace Tx in North America
  • Vicarious Surgical wins FDA breakthrough designation for surgical robot
  • Natus Medical issues field safety notice for snap electrode leads
  • J&J’s Ethicon gets to substitute 20 new claims on surgical stapler patent
  • Minerva Surgical raises $10m
  • Leo Pharma, Portal Instruments partner to develop needle-free drug delivery device
  • Orthofix names former Medtronic exec to lead global spine business
  • J&J Vision launches Tecnis Toric II intraocular lens in U.S.
  • NOUS Imaging picks up $6.6m for brain-imaging software

RSS From Medical Design & Outsourcing

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Need Medtech news in a minute?
We Deliver!

MassDevice Enewsletters get you caught up on all the mission critical news you need in med tech. Sign up today.

Popular Posts

  • Report: SEC probes GE Healthcare, Philips, Siemens in Chinese bribery scheme
  • Edwards Lifesciences warns against below-market mini-tender offer Edwards Lifesciences
  • J&J’s Ethicon files ITC complaint against Intuitive Surgical Intuitive Surgical's EndoWrist instruments
  • Auris Health loses motion to move Intuitive Surgical patent suit from Del. to Cali. Johnson & Johnson's Auris, Intuitive Surgical
  • Enable Injections inks deal with Sanofi for drug delivery platform enfuse-enable-injections
Tweets by @MassDevice
MDO ad

MASSDEVICE MEDICAL NETWORK

DeviceTalks
Drug Delivery Business News
Medical Design & Outsourcing
Medical Tubing + Extrusion

MASSDEVICE

Subscribe to MassDevice
Advertise with us
About
Contact us
Add us on FacebookMassDevice Network
Follow us on Twitter@MassDevice
Connect with us on LinkedInLinkedIn
Follow us on YouTube YouTube

Copyright © 2019 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Advertise | Privacy Policy | RSS