Smith & Nephew wants San Diego Chargers team doctor’s suit dismissed

Smith & Nephew wants San Diego Chargers team doctor's suit dismissed

Smith & Nephew (FTSE:SN, NYSE:SNN) wants a federal judge in California to toss a lawsuit filed by a doctor who blames a botched hip implantation on the British medical device company.

Dr. David Chao, the team physician for the NFL’s San Diego Chargers franchise, sued Smith & Nephew in the U.S. District Court for Southern California, alleging that inadequate training and faulty surgical scissors for SNN’s Birmingham Hip Resurfacing implant led to the botched surgery on Kathleen Adams in 2007.

Adams sued Chao for negligence, winning a $2.2 million settlement in 2008. Chao wants Smith & Nephew to cover the tab, accusing the company of training him and other doctors "to push the tips of the scissors into tissue in a manner such that the surgeon did not have a view of the tips of the scissor tines (i.e., ‘blind’ cuts)," according to court documents.

"Dr. Chao performed the BHR procedure on a patient who suffered significant complications and injuries caused by the BHR procedure, despite Dr. Chao precisely following the training provided by Smith & Nephew," according to the documents. "Smith & Nephew caused, in whole or at least substantial part, the loss and damage suffered by the patient and her husband, and in turn the losses suffered by plaintiffs in connection with the claim made against them arising from the BHR procedure performed on May 30, 2007. But for the defendants’ failure to properly develop reasonably safe procedures and related surgical equipment, and to provide appropriate training and warnings, the plaintiffs would have suffered no claim against them and would have sustained no loss."

But Smith & Nephew moved to have the case dismissed, arguing that federal law preempts any claims against it because the Birmingham device was approved by the FDA.

"Dr. Chao’s claims are expressly preempted by Section 360k(a) of the Medical Device Amendments of 1976, U.S.C. 360k(a). Because the BHR system is a Class III medical device that received pre-market approval from the FDA, federal law preempts state law claims that would impose conflicting or additional requirements on the BHR device. Dr. Chao’s contentions that the scissors were improperly designed and that the training and warnings for this device were inadequate either ‘conflict with’ or ‘are in addition to’ the federal requirements. Accordingly, Dr. Chao’s claims are preempted and should be dismissed," according to court documents.

It’s not the 1st time Chao has run into legal trouble, according to the San Diego Union-Tribune. In addition to a $7.5 million jury award in 1 case involving A jury awarded 1 former patient $7.5 million in damages in 1 case; in another case, a patient "suffered nerve damage from a hip resurfacing procedure in 2007," according to the newspaper, and another "who suffered a blood clot in one leg and a pseudoaneurysm after knee replacement surgery in 2010."

Chao has been sued by patients for malpractice, personal injury, negligence or fraud 20 times since 1998. California’s medical board is seeking to have his license revoked, according to the newspaper.

RSS From Medical Design & Outsourcing

  • Bayer rebrands material science biz as Covestro
    Bayer said the re-branding of its material sciences business as Covestro is complete, with a separate legal and economic structure for the Pittsburgh-based subsidiary ahead of a planned IPO next year. “Independence will enable us to bring our strengths to bear in global competition more quickly, effectively and flexibly,” Covestro CEO Patrick Thomas said in prepared […]
  • BRILAMET research project brought to successful conclusion: Precision laser-cutting technique optimized for thick metal sheets
    Using lasers to cut sheet metal is something that has typically been handled in the realm of CO₂ and fiber lasers, although this may not be the case for much longer. Diode lasers are increasingly emerging as the light source of choice for a large number of applications, as can be seen from the BRILAMET […]
  • Mobidiag and Unilabs enter into agreement over use of Amplidiag product line for molecular gastrointestinal diagnostics
    Mobidiag, a Finnish molecular diagnostics company specialized in the development of innovative diagnostics solutions for infectious diseases, and Unilabs, a diagnostics service provider, announced an agreement covering the supply of Amplidiag products over the next four years for Unilabs in Sweden and Norway. The Amplidiag product line covers six diagnostic products for various gastrointestinal infections, […]
  • Quick work keeps dental implants in place among women with osteoporosis
    As natural as aging is, it can tend to feel like a downward spiral. As the years increase, bone mass and strength decrease. Teeth can fall out, and the drugs and surgery designed to return things to normal may actually make bone related issues worse. Osteoporosis is a common problem for women who have gone […]
  • Cyberdyne CEO has severed spines on his agenda
    Editor’s Note: This article is from Bloomberg.com‘s Natasha Khan. Cyberdyne Inc.’s CEO, Yoshiyuki Sankai, is researching ways to repair damaged body tissue. The 57-year-old scientist’s vision: to treat patients with spinal injuries by using stem-cell related technology to repair nerve connections and robotic suits that aid movement. Sankai’s company is setting its sights on better […]
  • Teknor Apex to showcase wide range of PVC compounds for medical devices at Medtec China
    Building on its international leadership role as a supplier of medical-grade PVC compounds, Teknor Apex Company has developed flexible and rigid formulations that address the special needs of device manufacturers. The company will highlight these capabilities at Medtec China 2015. “Teknor Apex produces or markets medical-grade PVC compounds in China, Singapore, Europe, and the United […]
  • The Raspberry Pi eco-system goes interstellar with the new Raspberry Pi Sense HAT
    Newark element14 has globally launched the latest addition to the expanding ecosystem of Raspberry Pi accessories, the Raspberry Pi Sense HAT, as featured in the ‘Astro Pi’ space mission. The Sense HAT will enable enthusiasts to control the same hardware used in space. The Sense HAT attaches to the Raspberry Pi board, and can be […]
  • CommScope completes acquisition of TE Connectivity’s Telecom
    CommScope Holding Company, has completed its previously announced acquisition of TE Connectivity’s Telecom, Enterprise and Wireless businesses, a leader in fiber optic connectivity for wireline and wireless networks. The all-cash transaction, valued at approximately $3 billion, strengthens CommScope’s position as a leading communications infrastructure provider with deeper resources to meet the world’s growing demand for network […]
  • SPI awards IKO Prosthetic Creative System the Student Design International Design Excellence Award
    SPI: The Plastics Industry Trade Association congratulated IKO Prosthetic Creative System for winning the SPI Student Design Award, part of the Industrial Designers Society of America’s (IDSA’s) International Design Excellence Awards (IDEA) program. The award was presented to IKO, an innovative, youth-focused prosthetic design company led by Chicago-based designer Carlos Torres, by SPI’s Senior Director of […]
  • New assay could revolutionize diagnosis and treatment of life-threatening disease
    Invasive Fungal Disease (IFD) is an emerging global health problem associated with high mortality rates in severely immunocompromised patients, such as those undergoing intensive chemotherapy or stem cell transplantation, and in patients suffering immune compromising conditions such as AIDS. The most common causative agents of this disease have been identified as Candida and Aspergillus species, […]
  • Molex delivers ISO 13485-compliant, medical-grade surgical cables from its class 100,000 clean room facility
    Molex, LLC operates a fully ISO 146441-1:1999 Class 8-certified clean room, satisfying strict particulate contamination levels specified by ISO-compliant requirements. Located in Thailand, the facility has less than 100,000 particulates (≥0.5µm) per cubic foot of air and manufactures a variety of ISO 13485-compliant medical cables and surgical cables used in operating theatres, hospitals, laboratories and […]

Leave a Reply